Enter your email Address

ENTROPY
  • About
    • About
    • Masthead
    • Advertising
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Info on Book Reviews
  • Essays
    • All Introspection
      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      The Animal Form

      January 22, 2021

      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      On Fantasy and Artifice

      January 19, 2021

      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      Tales From the End of the Bus Line: Aging Ungraciously

      January 18, 2021

      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      Salt and Sleep

      January 15, 2021

      Introspection

      The Birds: A Special Providence in the Fall of a Sparrow

      January 2, 2020

      Introspection

      Returning Home with Ross McElwee

      December 13, 2019

      Introspection

      The Birds: In Our Piety

      November 14, 2019

      Introspection

      Variations: Landslide

      June 12, 2019

  • Fiction
    • Fiction

      The Birds: Little Birds

      December 11, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: Perdix and a Pear Tree

      December 9, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: A Glimmer of Blue

      November 23, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: Circling for Home

      November 13, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: The Guest

      November 9, 2020

  • Reviews
    • All Collaborative Review Video Review
      Review

      Review: Dear Marshall, Language is Our Only Wilderness by Heather Sweeney

      January 21, 2021

      Review

      Review: Shrapnel Maps by Philip Metres

      January 18, 2021

      Review

      Perceived Realities: A Review of M-Theory by Tiffany Cates

      January 14, 2021

      Review

      Review: Danger Days by Catherine Pierce

      January 11, 2021

      Collaborative Review

      Attention to the Real: A Conversation

      September 3, 2020

      Collaborative Review

      A Street Car Named Whatever

      February 22, 2016

      Collaborative Review

      Black Gum: A Conversational Review

      August 7, 2015

      Collaborative Review

      Lords of Waterdeep in Conversation

      February 25, 2015

      Video Review

      Entropy’s Super Mario Level

      September 15, 2015

      Video Review

      Flash Portraits of Link: Part 7 – In Weakness, Find Strength

      January 2, 2015

      Video Review

      Basal Ganglia by Matthew Revert

      March 31, 2014

      Video Review

      The Desert Places by Amber Sparks and Robert Kloss, Illustrated by Matt Kish

      March 21, 2014

  • Small Press
    • Small Press

      Gordon Hill Press

      December 8, 2020

      Small Press

      Evidence House

      November 24, 2020

      Small Press

      death of workers whilst building skyscrapers

      November 10, 2020

      Small Press

      Slate Roof Press

      September 15, 2020

      Small Press

      Ellipsis Press

      September 1, 2020

  • Where to Submit
  • More
    • Poetry
    • Interviews
    • Games
      • All Board Games Video Games
        Creative Nonfiction / Essay

        How Zelda Saved Me: The Inspiration, Feminism, and Empowerment of Hyrule

        November 2, 2020

        Board Games

        Session Report: Victoriana and Optimism

        December 14, 2019

        Games

        Best of 2019: Video Games

        December 13, 2019

        Games

        Hunt A Killer, Earthbreak, and Empty Faces: Escapism for the Post-Truth Era

        September 21, 2019

        Board Games

        Session Report: Victoriana and Optimism

        December 14, 2019

        Board Games

        Ludic Writing: Lady of the West

        July 27, 2019

        Board Games

        Session Report: Paperback and Anomia

        July 27, 2019

        Board Games

        Ludic Writing: The Real Leeds Part 12 (Once in a Lifetime)

        November 10, 2018

        Video Games

        How Zelda Saved Me: The Inspiration, Feminism, and Empowerment of Hyrule

        November 2, 2020

        Video Games

        Best of 2019: Video Games

        December 13, 2019

        Video Games

        Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is the Spirit of Generosity

        December 31, 2018

        Video Games

        Best of 2018: Video Games

        December 17, 2018

    • Food
    • Small Press Releases
    • Film
    • Music
    • Paranormal
    • Travel
    • Art
    • Graphic Novels
    • Comics
    • Current Events
    • Astrology
    • Random
  • RESOURCES
  • The Accomplices
    • THE ACCOMPLICES
    • Enclave
    • Trumpwatch

ENTROPY

  • About
    • About
    • Masthead
    • Advertising
    • Submission Guidelines
    • Info on Book Reviews
  • Essays
    • All Introspection
      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      The Animal Form

      January 22, 2021

      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      On Fantasy and Artifice

      January 19, 2021

      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      Tales From the End of the Bus Line: Aging Ungraciously

      January 18, 2021

      Creative Nonfiction / Essay

      Salt and Sleep

      January 15, 2021

      Introspection

      The Birds: A Special Providence in the Fall of a Sparrow

      January 2, 2020

      Introspection

      Returning Home with Ross McElwee

      December 13, 2019

      Introspection

      The Birds: In Our Piety

      November 14, 2019

      Introspection

      Variations: Landslide

      June 12, 2019

  • Fiction
    • Fiction

      The Birds: Little Birds

      December 11, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: Perdix and a Pear Tree

      December 9, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: A Glimmer of Blue

      November 23, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: Circling for Home

      November 13, 2020

      Fiction

      The Birds: The Guest

      November 9, 2020

  • Reviews
    • All Collaborative Review Video Review
      Review

      Review: Dear Marshall, Language is Our Only Wilderness by Heather Sweeney

      January 21, 2021

      Review

      Review: Shrapnel Maps by Philip Metres

      January 18, 2021

      Review

      Perceived Realities: A Review of M-Theory by Tiffany Cates

      January 14, 2021

      Review

      Review: Danger Days by Catherine Pierce

      January 11, 2021

      Collaborative Review

      Attention to the Real: A Conversation

      September 3, 2020

      Collaborative Review

      A Street Car Named Whatever

      February 22, 2016

      Collaborative Review

      Black Gum: A Conversational Review

      August 7, 2015

      Collaborative Review

      Lords of Waterdeep in Conversation

      February 25, 2015

      Video Review

      Entropy’s Super Mario Level

      September 15, 2015

      Video Review

      Flash Portraits of Link: Part 7 – In Weakness, Find Strength

      January 2, 2015

      Video Review

      Basal Ganglia by Matthew Revert

      March 31, 2014

      Video Review

      The Desert Places by Amber Sparks and Robert Kloss, Illustrated by Matt Kish

      March 21, 2014

  • Small Press
    • Small Press

      Gordon Hill Press

      December 8, 2020

      Small Press

      Evidence House

      November 24, 2020

      Small Press

      death of workers whilst building skyscrapers

      November 10, 2020

      Small Press

      Slate Roof Press

      September 15, 2020

      Small Press

      Ellipsis Press

      September 1, 2020

  • Where to Submit
  • More
    • Poetry
    • Interviews
    • Games
      • All Board Games Video Games
        Creative Nonfiction / Essay

        How Zelda Saved Me: The Inspiration, Feminism, and Empowerment of Hyrule

        November 2, 2020

        Board Games

        Session Report: Victoriana and Optimism

        December 14, 2019

        Games

        Best of 2019: Video Games

        December 13, 2019

        Games

        Hunt A Killer, Earthbreak, and Empty Faces: Escapism for the Post-Truth Era

        September 21, 2019

        Board Games

        Session Report: Victoriana and Optimism

        December 14, 2019

        Board Games

        Ludic Writing: Lady of the West

        July 27, 2019

        Board Games

        Session Report: Paperback and Anomia

        July 27, 2019

        Board Games

        Ludic Writing: The Real Leeds Part 12 (Once in a Lifetime)

        November 10, 2018

        Video Games

        How Zelda Saved Me: The Inspiration, Feminism, and Empowerment of Hyrule

        November 2, 2020

        Video Games

        Best of 2019: Video Games

        December 13, 2019

        Video Games

        Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is the Spirit of Generosity

        December 31, 2018

        Video Games

        Best of 2018: Video Games

        December 17, 2018

    • Food
    • Small Press Releases
    • Film
    • Music
    • Paranormal
    • Travel
    • Art
    • Graphic Novels
    • Comics
    • Current Events
    • Astrology
    • Random
  • RESOURCES
  • The Accomplices
    • THE ACCOMPLICES
    • Enclave
    • Trumpwatch
LiteratureTelevision

Yossarian Buendía in Macondo, Pianosa

written by Guest Contributor July 19, 2019

A Review of Hulu’s Catch-22 and Prognostications for Netflix’s One Hundred Years of Solitude

Once upon a time, Catch-22 by Joseph Heller was, according to Vanity Fair, “one of the greatest anti-war books ever written.” Now, it is a Hulu series. Already I can hear the conversation:

“Have you read Catch-22?”

“Read it? I mean, I’ve watched it but… is there a book too?”

Diehard bookworms and Heller devotees will cringe, and rightly so. As a voracious reader and avid fan of Heller myself, I’m tempted to rant about the despoilment of sacred literature by the pillaging plunderers of corporate film and television megalodons. But perhaps it isn’t all evil. Perhaps a Catch-22 TV series will inspire hooked viewers to read the novel and thence to explore more of the literary canon—thus making readers of watchers. (I know it’s naïve optimism, but what else do we have to go on?)

Moreover, putting sere crotchety foppishness aside, we must recognize the TV series for what it is becoming: an art form. Long existing solely in the realm of entertainment, television is undergoing a renaissance as contemporary directors uphold artistic ideals besides pursuing enthralling-engrossing entertainment. Oftentimes, this combination yields singularly artistic, intellectual results: Charlie Brooker’s Black Mirror and Daniel Percival’s The Man in High Castle engage philosophy and alternate history the same as Kurt Vonnegut’s Cat’s Cradle or Michael Chabon’s The Yiddish Policemen’s Union. If we draw a correlation between screen and stage, then TV shows correlate to the drama. As TV series become more indie and intellectual, eventually they too will constitute a form of high art like the film or the play.

Notably, with Grant Heslov, Ellen Kuras, and George Clooney’s screen adaptation of Catch-22 (2019), the TV series faced a test of its ability or willingness to secure high art status: for it to qualify as art, it seems that Clooney & Co. should have approached this novel with the respect one art form owes another, subordinating entertainment value to the reverent adaptation an artistic masterpiece deserves. Unfortunately, they largely failed to do that.

* * *

Equilibrium is, according to Merriam-Webster, “a state of adjustment between opposing or divergent influences or elements.” Equilibrium is also what makes Catch-22 the greatest antiwar novel of all time: repeatedly it rockets between humor and horror, between Yossarian losing his nerve and Snowden losing his guts. Heller, riding a fine line that encompasses wild laughs and bitter tears, achieves a sickening equilibrium that is unforgettably profound. Catch-22’s humor and horror cast each other into deep relief, forming the novel’s single dark shadow that gradually gut-punches, leaving a sharp ache and a vivid knowledge of war’s awful savagery.

Unfortunately, Hulu’s Catch-22 doesn’t quite generate the same emotional power. Granted, Clooney & Co.’s adaptation of Catch-22, incorporating much of the book’s richest comedy, gets the same laughs as the novel. Including all the book’s vomit-inducing tragedy, it jerks the same tears. But viewed comprehensively, the series falls flat, shattering into isolated points of emotion that never choate. Lacking a gut-punching whole, it fails where the book so smashingly succeeds.

There are three reasons for this insipidity. The first is Christopher Abbott’s portrayal of Yossarian. Abbott’s YoYo is too… ‘non-crazy.’ Don’t get me wrong: Yossarian is the sanest character because he realizes that “the enemy… is anyone who’s going to get you killed.” But sane doesn’t equate to non-crazy: Heller’s Yossarian acts erratically in order to “live forever or die in the attempt.” In fact, Catch-22’s essential irony is that precisely because Yossarian is sane, everyone thinks he’s crazy. Abbott’s YoYo, however, acts far too non-crazily.

The second reason is that the first four episodes don’t go ‘all in.’ Rather than achieving Heller’s maximum violence and comedy, they putter down the middle. Whether the delivery is frail (much Yossarian dialogue and every Doc Daneeka quip), the emphasis disproportionate (too much show-time to Milo) or the entirety excluded (e.g. Chief White Halfoat and Hungry Joe), Hulu’s Catch-22 is skim milk everywhere it should be whole.

The third reason, however, is the irredeemable, irremediable death blow. In the show’s penultimate scene, YoYo responds to fresh Lieutenant Newman’s, “Are you ok?” with an uncharacteristic, protector-of-the-innocent bear hug; in the ultimate scene, YoYo contently flies a mission with his formation. This denouement doesn’t belong in Catch-22—a selfish tale of desertion. Yossarian is a yellow-bellied coward who lies, attempts desertion and covers up rape so he can go home. In the novel, he flees to Sweden. According to Clooney & Co., however, Yossarian inexplicably morphs into Big Brother’s model soldier. In short, Hulu’s Catch-22 betrays the work’s essential message.

* * *

On March 6, Netflix announced it had acquired the rights to Gabriel García Márquez’s novel One Hundred Years of Solitude. After watching Catch-22, I found myself asking, “Will Netflix’s One Hundred Years of Solitude be this bad?” The novels are extremely similar: both a-chronologically develop an absurdist plot; both have humorous, ironic third-person-omniscient narrators; both are saturated with crescendoing corruption, violence, loneliness and death; both grapple with existence in a postmodern, unfathomable world symbolized by Pianosa and Macondo. How tragic if both reached the same fate: televised desecration.

But Heller’s novel is grotesque while Márquez’s novel is magical. And this protects One Hundred Years of Solitude from onscreen corruption. For nothing on television is real. Like magic, it is the antithesis of reality (even reality TV involves predetermined camera angles, scene selections, edits and cuts). Simultaneously, television leaves nothing to the imagination: it sets everything before the viewer’s eyes in high-definition color. What’s there is all that’s there.

Grotesque fiction, on the other hand, relies entirely on reality and imagination to function. The grotesque novelist must employ ample realism – what the author Flannery O’Connor terms “concrete” – to evoke the reader’s experienced reality and thereby bring the novel to life. The reader absorbs and interprets this provided concrete according to their imagination and experienced concrete. This individual interpretation privately animates the story in an unverifiable yet veritably vivid way. Then – so powerful is the novel’s animation due to the reader’s identification with the concrete – the author can introduce imaginary, impossibly grotesque scenes while maintaining the grotesque’s verisimilitude.

In other words, Catch-22 never had a chance onscreen. The grotesque cannot maintain its grotesqueness when, unimagined, it visually occurs in the nonreality of the TV, leaving nothing to individual imaginations. Rather, grotesque must occur in the fertile Wonderlands of individual imaginations, animated by experienced realities privately reconstructed at the author’s direction—not onscreen, surrounded by a common ‘reality’ that is actually a stage. Perhaps, then, we can absolve Clooney & Co. of Catch-22’s perversion.

In short, grotesque novels rely on our private re-creations of their concrete, on our ability to fundamentally enter into their realities. And TV absolutely inhibits personal re-creation. But One Hundred Years of Solitude is not grotesque. It is magical realism. As such, the magical laws of its universe differ from our natural laws. And as such, it will work onscreen. Because magical realism, with its fundamentally different laws, makes us all outsiders—just like TV. Of course we can connect with the verisimilitude, the detail and apparent reality of One Hundred Years of Solitude. We can relate to characters and comprehend their ecstasies and tribulations. Nevertheless, we are strangers peering into a different world.

This is why One Hundred Years of Solitude will work on TV. We are outsiders both when reading Márquez’s novel and when watching television. We are peering into separate universes. The causes differ: with Márquez’s novel, the magical laws radically differing from our natural laws make us observers; with TV, the exclusion of imagination makes us viewers. But the results are identical. We are outsiders.

Therefore, One Hundred Years of Solitude will fit perfectly on TV. Television’s viewership effect parallels the observer-ship effect of peering into Márquez’s magical, maniacal Macondo. No, the characters will not appear as you envision them. Yes, the director will cut scenes you consider indispensable. But the estranging character of TV will in no way inhibit a potentially beautiful adaptation of One Hundred Years of Solitude as it did Catch-22. And if Netflix selects an artistic, talented director and, using a Spanish screenplay, maintains Márquez’s lyrical, stunning, impeccable prose, I expect a truly artistic, intellectual bingeing experience when they release One Hundred Years of Solitude—if the term “intellectual bingeing” isn’t an oxymoron only possible in a magical or grotesque universe. I hope it’s not.


W. Trace Miller is a writer based in Dallas, Texas. He is also the assistant managing editor of the Richland Chronicle, the official student newspaper serving Richland College’s body of 20,000 students. Some of his most recent publishings include a map for Eater Dallas, a critical review of Billie Eilish’s album “When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?” and a comparative literature essay for the Tulsa Review.

Yossarian Buendía in Macondo, Pianosa was last modified: July 19th, 2019 by Guest Contributor
adaptationliteraturetelevision
0 comment
0
Facebook Twitter Google + Pinterest
Avatar
Guest Contributor

Entropy posts are often submitted to us by our fantastic readers & guest contributors. We'd love to receive a contribution from you too. Submission Guidelines.

previous post
The Loose Ends of Loss: When Someone Dies Mad At You
next post
South Central

You may also like

Elise Cowen: Poems and Fragments

March 25, 2016

National Poetry Month Featured Poet: Cassandra Gillig

April 21, 2014

Super Mario Bros. 2

November 13, 2014

Foreign Soil / An Elegant Young Man / Captives

July 1, 2014
Facebook Twitter Instagram

Recent Comments

  • Lei Yu wow so beautifully written!

    Review – : once teeth bones coral : by Kimberly Alidio ·  January 18, 2021

  • Lisa S Thank you so much for your kind words and your feedback. I can only hope my story is able to help someone who needs it.

    WOVEN: This isn’t love ·  January 8, 2021

  • Ann Guy Thank you, Josh. And glad you didn’t get tetanus at band camp on that misguided day.

    A Way Back Home ·  December 24, 2020

Featured Columns & Series

  • The Birds
  • Dinnerview
  • WOVEN
  • Variations on a Theme
  • BLACKCACKLE
  • Literacy Narrative
  • COVID-19
  • Mini-Syllabus
  • Their Days Are Numbered
  • On Weather
  • Disarticulations
  • The Waters
  • Session Report series
  • Birdwolf
  • Comics I've Been Geeking Out On
  • Small Press Releases
  • Books I Hate (and Also Some I Like)
  • The Poetics of Spaces
  • Fog or a Cloud
  • Tales From the End of the Bus Line
  • 30 Years of Ghibli
  • Cooking Origin Stories
  • YOU MAKE ME FEEL
  • Ludic Writing
  • Best of 2019
  • The Talking Cure
  • Stars to Stories
  • DRAGONS ARE REAL OR THEY ARE DEAD
  • Foster Care
  • Food and Covid-19
  • LEAKY CULTURE
  • Jem and the Holographic Feminisms
  • D&D with Entropy

Find Us On Facebook

Entropy
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

©2014-2020 The Accomplices LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Read our updated Privacy Policy.


Back To Top